What Would Union Dues Actually Cost?
Dues cost was the number one concern reported in the recent MiraCosta Classified
employee survey. That makes the structure of the dues, not just the stated percentage,
important. Organizers are talking with two unions and holding information sessions for
employees to ask questions and compare them before anything is final.
The main difference: CSEA dues have an annual cap, while the AFT continues to increase with salary.
CSEA: a capped annual maximum
$500/year
Estimated maximum, includes estimated 2.75 local dues
CSEA state dues stop increasing once the annual cap is reached. Under the
assumptions used here, the maximum deduction would be $50 in each of 10 paid months.
AFT Guild: percentage of all gross pay
1.5% + $2.75
Of gross pay, 2.75 is estimated monthly local dues to support the MCC unit
Under the published San Diego AFT Guild example, dues continue increasing as
salary increases because the percentage applies to all gross pay. This comparison
adds the same assumed $2.75 in local dues each month.
Estimated annual and payroll-period dues at representative salary levels
| Annual salary |
AFT monthly (12 months) |
AFT annual |
CSEA deduction (10 months) |
CSEA annual |
Annual savings with CSEA |
| $30,000 |
$40.25 |
$483.00 |
$40.25 |
$402.50 |
$80.50 |
| $50,000 |
$65.25 |
$783.00 |
$50.00 |
$500.00 |
$283.00 |
| $80,000 |
$102.75 |
$1,233.00 |
$50.00 |
$500.00 |
$733.00 |
| $100,000 |
$127.75 |
$1,533.00 |
$50.00 |
$500.00 |
$1,033.00 |
| $120,000 |
$152.75 |
$1,833.00 |
$50.00 |
$500.00 |
$1,333.00 |
The practical difference: CSEA's cap makes the cost more predictable.
At an $80,000 annual salary, the estimated CSEA total would be $500 per year, which is
$733 less than the AFT Guild example after including the same assumed local dues. At
$100,000, the estimated difference would be $1,033 per year.
Dues would not begin merely because someone signs a card. They would apply only after
employees vote to unionize and a chapter is formed.
Assumptions: Salary is paid over 12 months. CSEA figures assume
10 payroll deductions per year and $2.75 in local dues per deduction. The AFT
comparison assumes 1.5% of gross pay over 12 paid months, plus the same $2.75 in
local dues for each of the 12 deductions. The $21 minimum does not affect the salary
examples shown.
CSEA source: CSEA states that annual state dues are 1.5% of the
first $3,150 of monthly gross salary, capped at $472.50 annually. Local chapters may
assess additional dues.
View the CSEA dues information.
AFT comparison source: A published SDCCD AFT Guild membership
packet states dues of 1.5% of gross pay, with a $21 minimum, for each month in paid
status. This comparison is illustrative and is not a dues quote for MiraCosta employees.
View the SDCCD membership packet.
Dues rates and local assessments can change. Confirm the final structure with each
union before an election or formal membership campaign.